This is my first review of a full read for the Peripheral Prospectors judging team for the semifinal round of SPSFC#4. For more information about the team and our progress, please go to the team update page here.

The book is Saint Elspeth by Wick Welker. The book is available from Amazon.

Blurb

When they appeared across the sky, speculation wheeled around the world—the aliens were from heaven, the invaders were from hell… or they were proof that neither existed. But when they landed, curiosity gave way to suspicion and the nations reacted with nuclear force, setting off a chain reaction that left the world in ruins.

Twenty years later, instead of nearing her retirement, Dr. Elspeth Darrow struggles to forget the loss of her child and husband by plunging herself into the work of operating the last remaining hospital in San Francisco. With medical supplies running out and working herself to exhaustion, Elspeth must embark on a risky salvage mission into the heart of the Neo California danger zone. Here, she discovers the disturbing truth: the aliens have returned.

As the mystery of the aliens’ purpose on Earth unravels before her, Elspeth must hide what she discovers from reactionary despots, all vying to bring Neo California under their control. Aided by a band of pre-war scientists and new-world medical students, Elspeth races against astronomical odds to reveal the terrifying truth that might save the world—or finally destroy it for good.

My Review

This was a really engaging read for me. It wades deep into fertile sci-fi waters, with elements of post-apocalyptic fiction, alien invasion, and first contact. There are deep mysteries to figure out, but there’s also the unrelenting struggle and pressure of humans trying to survive in the wreckage of 21st century society, greatly diminished.

Plot and Characters

I can’t say much about the plot here, because a lot of what I might get into would be spoilers. The setup, though, is that we’re following a jaded, broken woman, the Elspeth of the title, who runs an understaffed and undersupplied clinic in the ruins of San Francisco. After the appearance of organic alien pod ships in the skies, there was a fairly extensive nuclear exchange as humanity struggled with how to respond and fell to fractious wars. Small groups of humans hunkered down in bunkers until it was safe to emerge, and now they are back above ground trying to make a go of it. The aliens, the Hilamen, never took action against the humans, and nobody can really figure out what their purpose was.

Elspeth has a great voice, and her weariness and cynicism combine with perseverance and compassion to create an engaging and conflicted character, one who you can certainly cheer for. She occasionally drifts towards somewhat frustrating maudlin spells, but those are understandable, even if they don’t necessarily move the story forward. She’s got a past (and present) full of loss, and she thinks she’s going through the motions in her clinic just because she doesn’t have anything better to do.

There are a host of side characters, good and evil (or both), venal and noble (or both), heroic and dissipated (or both). Almost everybody in the book is complex and rich, which is a real treat.

My Thoughts

I mused about halfway through that reading this felt like I was playing Fallout or The Last of Us, which was funny, because Welker says in the author’s note that he was playing The Last of Us while writing. There are some great post-apocalyptic tropes here, with ruined buildings, nature taking over, and people succumbing to bravado and militarism, hoarding salvaged resources, and facing hardships now that society and its laws and comforts have vanished. There are even giraffes from the zoo, which must be a TLoU homage. All of this part works well and seems gritty and believable.

There’s the additional dimension of the mystery of the Hilamen, who initially seem not to be doing anything. They just arrived, inadvertently triggered humanity to tear itself to pieces, landed, and vanished. That mystery is a really fun one, and it has a satisfying answer that’s pieced together as the story unfolds.

There is a ton of very real-sounding medical procedure in here, which makes sense, as Welker is an ICU doctor. There’s also some very interesting xenobiology. That part is left a little mysterious, although it’s partially explained in the plot through scientific observation by people making reasonable guesses based on the information they have. I couldn’t tell you at the end exactly how the Hilamen work in terms of physics and biochemistry, but there’s enough there to be satisfying.

Where I had more questions was with the climate and environment and politics of this post apocalyptic world. The social structure of the various California colonies is well-described, and the future history makes sense. There are occasional references to other parts of the world, but the geoscientist in me wanted to know a little more about the extent and distribution of the fallout, not to mention the climate change that seems to have engulfed parts of California and caused sinkholes and flooding and formation of significant new rivers. The sci-fi fan in me wanted to know better how the rest of the world was functioning too. But what we get is engaging and real enough, and those parts aren’t the focus of the story, and going into more detail wouldn’t really have added anything useful to what’s already a pretty long narrative.

The pace of discovery, the use of the scientific method, the victories and losses, the questions of morality and human nature, and the odd but satisfying way many characters had of changing their own goals and mindset in response to their experiences all contributed to a rip-roaring narrative full of interesting pieces.

The book is very well-written and well edited, with only a handful of typos in what would be a 400-page large-size paperback. Welker’s use of metaphor and imagery is really neat – not overwhelming or flowery, just fun and a little magical when it shows up.

Summation

I greatly enjoyed my time with this. Elspeth is a really engaging character, and her voice and attitude are refreshing even in a world that is mostly going to hell. Amidst the ruin and brutishness, there is some hope (mixed with despair and ambition, to be sure), and the story takes you along a number of unexpected but rewarding turns along a road to a satisfying conclusion. This is a really good book, tightly crafted, full of adventure and humanity, and quite worthy of the SPSFC semifinals.